Thin Mint Ice Cream

Vegan Thin Mint Ice Cream

Looking for something to do with your leftover* Girl Scout Cookies? The next best thing to eating the cookies in their purest form is making a new dessert featuring the cookies. This Thin Mint Chip Ice Cream, for example.

*And I’m going to assume the only reason you’d have leftovers is because you bought four or five boxes.

Girl Scout Thin Mint Ice Cream Recipe (vegan and dairy free) | Seitan Beats Your Meat

 

A few months ago, my girlfriend came home from a visit to New York with an assortment of Girl Scout Cookies. She filled our cabinets with Lemonades and Thanks-A-Lots and lined the freezer with shiny sleeves of Thin Mints. After eating cookies out of the freezer for a few weeks, I decided to use a sleeve for an ice cream experiment.

Before ordering a case of Girl Scout cookies, do your homework. The veganness of Girl Scout Cookies varies by manufacturer (for Thin Mints especially), and the manufacturer varies by US region. Thin Mints from ABC Bakers are free of animal ingredients, but Thin Mints from Little Brownie Bakers are not vegan. Get the lowdown on the varieties of vegan Girl Scout Cookies from The Laziest Vegans, and the ABC Bakers FAQ.

Update 2017: Good news: all Thin Mints are now vegan! Of course, check the ingredients and the latest information when ordering in the future because ingredients and recipes change every so often.

 

Vegan Thin Mint Ice Cream

I find that using coconut cream as a base for homemade ice creams yields the creamiest texture, even after freezing completely. It does add some coconut flavor to your ice cream, so keep that in mind when choosing flavors for your ice cream, or replace with another high-fat non-dairy milk or cream.

To get the cream from a can of full fat coconut milk by letting it sit at room temperature, undisturbed, for a day, then chilling it for another day. The cream will rise to the top and solidify so you can scoop it out and use it in a recipe. While this is not a complicated process, you do have to plan ahead. Therefore, I was happy to find that Trader Joe’s carries cans of coconut cream! Not to be confused with the sugary liquid used in piña coladas that is also called “coconut cream” and also comes in a can, this coconut cream contains just the cream from coconut milk. Trader Joe’s is the only place I’ve found this, so let me know if you have another source. When in doubt, read labels.

Once the logistics of your cookie and coconut cream acquisition are complete, it’s time for dessert. This refreshing mint green ice cream loaded with cookies and chocolate beats the dairy Thin Mint Ice Cream any day.

Thin Mint Ice Cream recipe

Thin Mint Ice Cream
 
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
Vegan Girl Scout Thin Mint ice cream made with coconut cream, cookies, and chocolate chips
Author:
Recipe type: Dessert
Cuisine: Vegan, Vegetarian, Dairy-Free, Egg-Free
Serves: 1 1/2 pints
Ingredients
  • 14 ounces coconut cream
  • ¾ cup sugar
  • 1 cup non-dairy milk
  • 2-2 ½ teaspoons peppermint extract
  • ½ teaspoon vanilla extract
  • Green food coloring (optional)
  • 10 Thin Mints
  • ¼ cup chocolate chips, chopped
Instructions
  1. Combine coconut cream and sugar in a small saucepan and cook over medium heat until the sugar is dissolved.
  2. Remove from heat and stir in the milk, extracts, and food coloring, if using. Let cool.
  3. Keep the chocolate and Thin Mints in the freezer until it’s time to add them to the ice cream so the ice cream maintains its temperature when you add the chocolate and cookies.
  4. Freeze in an ice cream maker according to the manufacturer’s instructions, adding the Thin Mints and chocolate during the last five minutes of freezing.
  5. Serve garnished with extra Thin Mints, and chocolate syrup, if desired. Enjoy!

Thin Mint Ice Cream

You may have noticed that Seitan Beats Your Meat took an unexpected hiatus over the past several months. Adding a full-time job to my schedule, moving to Chicago, and living out of boxes for a little while got in the way of creating recipes, doing photoshoots, and hoping to make posts on a regular basis. Now that life has settled down quite a bit and I have a place to live with everything unpacked for the first time in a year, I’ll be back with content (and maybe post some photos of my new kitchen and workspace!). I’ll still focus on quality over quantity, but gaps between posts will be weeks, not months.

I’d also like to announce that I’m vending at Paper Moon Pastry‘s upcoming Vegan Vortex Market in Chicago this Saturday! I will have copies of Cheers to Vegan Sweets, zines, and other fun stuff at my table. The market is a showcase of local vegan businesses, authors, and artists so you’ll find food, dessert, handmade gifts, books, art, and more. All of the details are on the Facebook event. Come on by for lunch and check out the goods!

Vegan Vortex Kelly Peloza

I’ll be back very soon with another recipe and post!

What is your favorite Girl Scout cookie?

Kelly Peloza is the blogger and photographer at Seitan Beats Your Meat, and the author of two vegan cookbooks: The Vegan Cookie Connoisseur, and Cheers to Vegan Sweets.

She lives in Chicago and runs a photography business called Kelly Peloza Photo.

5 Replies to “Thin Mint Ice Cream”

  1. I have leftover thin mints to make this!

  2. What is leftover cookie?

  3. […] posted a recipe for Thin Mint Ice Cream over on Seitan Beats Your Meat! Use vegan Girl Scout Cookies or homemade Thin Mints from The Vegan […]

  4. […] that coconut cream yields the creamiest vegan ice cream. As I mentioned in my last ice cream post, Thin Mint Ice Cream, you can now buy Trader Joe’s coconut cream in a can without the hassle of separating the fat […]

Leave a Reply